Looking for a When I Work alternative? See exactly how Netchex compares.
When I Work is a well-regarded shift scheduling and time-tracking tool for hourly teams, but it stops at getting hours out to a separate payroll system. Netchex is known for getting payroll right and picking up the phone. Here’s the real, side-by-side comparison: features, support scores, and what actual switchers say.
7,500+ organizations trust Netchex
Netchex vs. When I Work, in one paragraph.
When I Work is a genuinely well-regarded scheduling and time-tracking tool, built for hourly, deskless teams and consistently praised for ease of use. What it is not is a payroll platform. It exports hours to ADP, Paychex, Gusto, and similar providers so payroll can run somewhere else, which means a business still runs two systems and keeps them in sync by hand. Netchex runs scheduling, time and attendance, payroll, and HR from one platform, with no export-and-re-enter step. Netchex holds a 4.5/5 rating on G2 across 7,500+ businesses, answers 90% of support calls in under a minute with first-call resolution, and includes a free, project-managed implementation that runs about 6 weeks.
Choose When I Work if:
You only need shift scheduling and time tracking for an hourly team and already have a payroll system you are happy to keep running separately.
Choose Netchex if:
You want scheduling, time and attendance, payroll, and HR in one system, with one login and no manual hand-off of hours between two separate tools.
Netchex and When I Work, side by side.
| Netchex | When I Work | |
|---|---|---|
| Core product | Payroll, HR, time and attendance, and scheduling, in one platform | Shift scheduling and time tracking only, payroll is not native |
| G2 rating | 4.5/5 (7,500+ businesses) | 4.4/5 (approximately 375 reviews, figure varies by source)* |
| G2 support score | 8.9/10 | Not documented in this research |
| Best fit company size | 50-5,000 employees | Hourly, deskless teams needing scheduling only |
| Payroll | Native, integrated with time and attendance | Not native, exports hours to ADP, Paychex, Gusto, or QuickBooks |
| Implementation | Free, project-managed, about 6 weeks, dedicated Implementation Manager | Self-serve setup, 14-day free trial |
| Ongoing support | Dedicated Account Manager. 90% of calls answered in under a minute, with first-call resolution. | Not documented in this research |
| Number of systems to keep in sync | One | At least two, scheduling and a separate payroll system |
| Mobile app | Strong, high daily adoption | Reviewers describe app glitches and heavy notification volume as recurring complaints* |
| Documented tax filing issues | None reported | Not applicable, does not run payroll |
*Rows marked with an asterisk cite third-party review sources (G2). Data collected as of September 2026 and subject to change.
Why companies switch from When I Work to Netchex.
Payroll is a separate step, not a built-in one
When I Work gets hours to a payroll system, it does not run payroll itself. That means a manual or semi-automated hand-off between two tools every pay period, an extra point of failure Netchex removes by running scheduling and payroll on one platform.
Scheduling that does not solve the whole problem
Per G2 review commentary, some users report that a standalone scheduling tool “is not solving their problems” and found it less convenient than scheduling built directly inside their payroll system, a direct data point for the case to consolidate.
App glitches and notification overload
Reviewers cite app glitches and an overwhelming volume of notifications as recurring complaints, friction that adds up for a workforce that relies on the app every shift.
Two systems to administer instead of one
Even when the hand-off between When I Work and a payroll provider works smoothly, it is still two logins, two support relationships, and two places data can drift out of sync. Netchex’s real advantage for a When I Work user is not a longer feature list, it is consolidation.
| Netchex | When I Work | |
|---|---|---|
| Calls answered in under 1 minute | 90% | Not documented in this research |
| First-call resolution | 90% | Not documented in this research |
| Customer satisfaction | 98% (97% most recent reading) | Not documented in this research |
| Account manager | Dedicated | Not documented in this research |
| Ranking | #1 on G2 for Service | Not documented in this research |
Where Netchex and When I Work actually differ.
Payroll built in, not exported elsewhere.
Netchex guarantees accurate, on-time payroll with no documented tax-filing failures, run on the same platform where hours are tracked. When I Work does not run payroll at all, it exports hours to ADP, Paychex, Gusto, or QuickBooks for processing elsewhere.
Scheduling and payroll on the same rail.
Netchex includes native shift differentials, piece rate pay, and geofenced or biometric clocking, flowing directly into payroll with no export step. When I Work is genuinely strong at scheduling and shift swaps for hourly teams, but hours still have to leave the platform to reach payroll.
A dedicated team, from rollout to renewal.
Every Netchex client gets a dedicated Implementation Manager for a free, project-managed rollout that typically takes about 6 weeks, followed by a dedicated Account Manager for the life of the relationship. When I Work offers a 14-day free trial and self-serve setup, a lighter-touch model suited to a single-purpose scheduling tool.
One login, one data flow, from schedule to paycheck.
When I Work is a real, well-regarded scheduling tool, reviewers consistently praise its ease of use for shift swaps, availability, and team messaging. The gap is scope: it stops at getting hours to a separate payroll system. Netchex runs scheduling, time and attendance, payroll, and HR from one platform, so hours never have to leave the system to become a paycheck.
Fewer surprises on the invoice.
Netchex includes free, project-managed implementation and data import with no setup fee. When I Work prices scheduling and a separate time-tracking add-on individually, worth factoring in since most shift-based businesses need both, not just scheduling alone.
What switching to Netchex actually sounds like.
“We used to print out each email and application, sometimes hundreds a day, write who it was for, and then go stick it in that manager’s mailbox. Now we don’t have to do any of that since we use NetRecruiter. So much less paper and so much less time spent on it.”
“Netchex has been fantastic. We enjoy personalized service, we know the people that we deal with, and they bend over backward to get what we need done.”
“Netchex is the Chick-fil-a of payroll providers.”
“I love the integrated platform. With our old payroll company you would have to make the same change in several different areas of the software. With Netchex, it only takes once. This system is so user-friendly, it makes training a breeze. And the customer service is second to none!”
“Netchex has the best support of any service provider I’ve ever worked with. There aren’t any hoops to jump through with Netchex support.”
“Coming from an in-house payroll company and moving to Netchex has opened so many wonderful doors. Netchex provides so much assistance with my payroll and HR needs, allowing me more time with other important duties.”
When I Work vs. Netchex, answered.
Do When I Work and Netchex offer similar features?
Does When I Work include payroll?
What size companies are the best fit for When I Work vs. Netchex?
Who has better customer service, When I Work or Netchex?
How does When I Work pricing compare to Netchex?
Can I use When I Work for scheduling and Netchex for payroll?
Comparing other HR and payroll providers?
See how Netchex stacks up against other scheduling and time-tracking tools.
See why 7,500+ businesses picked Netchex over When I Work.
Get a live demo built around your industry, not a generic feature tour.
Request a Demo