4.5/5 on G2 · 7,500+ businesses

Looking for a PrimePay alternative? See exactly how Netchex compares.

PrimePay built its reputation on COBRA administration. But a 2025 merger with the PEO CoAdvantage, both owned by the same private equity firm, has raised real questions about where PrimePay is headed as a standalone platform. Netchex is independently run, with a dedicated Account Manager for every client. Here’s the real, side-by-side comparison.

Request a Demo See the Comparison

7,500+ organizations trust Netchex

Netchex vs. PrimePay, in one paragraph.

PrimePay has a long-documented strength in COBRA administration, and its platform includes the standard payroll, time, and benefits modules companies expect. But in 2025, PrimePay merged with CoAdvantage, a professional employer organization, under the same private equity owner, Aquiline Capital, and PrimePay’s own pricing page now redirects to CoAdvantage’s site. That’s raised a real, source-acknowledged question about whether PrimePay continues as its own product. Netchex has been independently run for 20 years, with a dedicated Account Manager on every account and no accuracy issues cited in the reviews we found. PrimePay reviewers, by contrast, report a payroll accuracy error that triggered a tax notice and support that slows down after implementation.

Choose PrimePay if:

COBRA administration is a priority for your business, you already have a relationship with PrimePay or CoAdvantage, and you’re comfortable with some uncertainty about the platform’s direction after the 2025 merger.

Choose Netchex if:

you want an independently run provider with a dedicated Account Manager, a clean payroll accuracy record, and no recent private-equity ownership changes affecting the roadmap.

At a Glance

Netchex and PrimePay, side by side.

	Netchex	PrimePay
Ownership stability	Independently run 20 years	Merged with CoAdvantage PEO (2025), same PE owner
G2 rating	4.5/5 (7,500+ businesses)	4.2/5 (97 reviews) (G2, checked 2026-09-11)
G2 support score	8.9/10	Not documented in this research
Dedicated Account Manager	Every customer	Reviewers report support slows after implementation
Implementation	Free, project-managed, about 6 weeks	Approximately 3 months, buyer-reported average (G2, checked 2026-09-11)
Time & Attendance	Native module	Included
Benefits Administration	In-house licensed team	Included, with COBRA administration as a longtime strength
Payroll accuracy track record	No accuracy issues cited in reviews	Reviewers report accuracy errors and tax notices
Best fit company size	50-5,000 employees	Up to roughly 2,000 employees, core segment 10-100 employees; G2 reviewer base skews small-business (64.2%) (G2, checked 2026-09-11)
Reporting and analytics	Not directly compared in this research	Reviewers report reports were hard to find and customize

Rows marked “Not documented in this research” reflect the limits of publicly available, source-verified data on PrimePay as of this writing, not a claim that PrimePay lacks the feature. Data collected as of September 2026 and subject to change.

Why Companies Switch

Why companies switch from PrimePay to Netchex.

Ownership uncertainty after the CoAdvantage merger

In 2025, PrimePay merged with CoAdvantage, a PEO, and both companies are owned by the same private equity firm, Aquiline Capital. PrimePay’s own pricing page now redirects to CoAdvantage, which raises a real question about whether PrimePay stays a standalone HCM platform or gets folded into a co-employment model.

Reporting that’s hard to use

Reviewer feedback found in this research points to a platform that makes it difficult to locate and customize reports, a real friction point for HR teams that rely on regular reporting.

“Reports through the platform were hard to find and customize.”– PrimePay reviewer

Support that slows down after go-live

More than one reviewer cited in this research described a drop-off in support responsiveness once implementation wrapped up, a pattern also seen with several other competitors in this space.

“Support slowed down noticeably after implementation.”– PrimePay reviewer

Payroll accuracy and tax notices

At least one documented reviewer account describes a payroll accuracy error that led directly to a tax notice, a compliance-consequence complaint in the same category as issues raised about several other providers.

“We saw a payroll accuracy error that triggered a tax notice.”– PrimePay reviewer

	Netchex	PrimePay
Calls answered in under 1 minute	90%	Not documented in this research
First-call resolution	90%	Not documented in this research
Customer satisfaction	98% (97% most recent reading)	Not documented in this research
Account manager	Dedicated	Reviewers report support slows after implementation
Ranking	#1 on G2 for Service	Not documented in this research

Feature Deep-Dive

Where Netchex and PrimePay actually differ.

Ownership Stability

One steady owner for 20 years, not a PE roll-up in progress.

Netchex has been independently run for 20 years. PrimePay merged with the PEO CoAdvantage in 2025 under the same private equity owner, Aquiline Capital, and its pricing page now points visitors to CoAdvantage’s site instead of its own.

Company Structure

Netchex OwnershipIndependent, 20 yrs

PrimePay OwnershipMerged with CoAdvantage

PE FirmAquiline Capital

Service & Account Management

A dedicated Account Manager, not a rotating help desk.

Every Netchex client gets a dedicated Account Manager for the life of the relationship, backed by a team that answers 90% of calls in under a minute with first-call resolution. PrimePay reviewers cited in this research report support that noticeably slows down once implementation is complete.

Support Snapshot

Calls Answered <1 Min90%

First-Call Resolution90%

Dedicated Account ManagerEvery Client

Benefits Administration & COBRA

Where PrimePay genuinely leads.

This is a real PrimePay strength: COBRA administration has been a longtime differentiator for the platform. Netchex also runs benefits administration through an in-house, licensed benefits team, but doesn’t single out COBRA as its own signature capability the way PrimePay does.

Benefits Coverage

Netchex Benefits TeamIn-house, licensed

PrimePay COBRA AdminLongtime strength

Open Enrollment SupportBoth platforms

Time & Attendance

Native on both platforms, with different depth.

Netchex includes Time & Attendance as a native module built for hourly and multi-location teams. PrimePay includes Time & Attendance as well, though this research didn’t turn up the same level of detail on shift differentials, piece rate pay, or geofenced clocking that Netchex documents for its own platform.

Time Tracking

Netchex Time & AttendanceNative module

PrimePay Time & AttendanceIncluded

Configuration DepthNot documented

Payroll Accuracy

A clean track record versus a documented tax notice.

Netchex has no accuracy issues cited in the reviews found for this research. PrimePay reviewers, by contrast, report a payroll accuracy error serious enough to trigger an actual tax notice, a real compliance consequence rather than a minor complaint.

Payroll Accuracy

Netchex Accuracy Issues CitedNone found

PrimePay Accuracy Issues CitedReviewer-reported

Tax Notice ReportedYes, PrimePay

Customer Proof

What switching to Netchex actually sounds like.

★★★★★

“Coming from an in-house payroll company and moving to Netchex has opened so many wonderful doors. Netchex provides so much assistance with my payroll and HR needs, allowing me more time with other important duties.”

Belinda CanalesPayroll Coordinator/HR

★★★★★

“I love the integrated platform. With our old payroll company you would have to make the same change in several different areas of the software. With Netchex, it only takes once. This system is so user-friendly, it makes training a breeze. And the customer service is second to none!”

Chris HayesPayroll Specialist

★★★★★

“Netchex has been fantastic. We enjoy personalized service, we know the people that we deal with, and they bend over backward to get what we need done.”

Margaret DethloffPayroll Administrator

★★★★★

“Netchex is wonderful. Everyone has been continuously impressed by the services they provide. Back when the new ACA regulations went into place, and even now with the whole COVID-19 situation, Netchex just continues to knock it out of the park.”

Laura DickersonHR Director

★★★★★

“Netchex has the best support of any service provider I’ve ever worked with. There aren’t any hoops to jump through with Netchex support.”

Mary LangAccounting and Financial Control Director, Atlanta Air Charter, Inc.

★★★★★

“The entire staff, from sales to implementation to service, has been stellar in their delivery. The culture of Netchex is one of a company that demonstrates the importance of relationships with clients.”

David FauncePartner, KM Consulting

FAQs

PrimePay vs. Netchex, answered.

Is PrimePay still an independent company?

Not entirely. In 2025, PrimePay merged with CoAdvantage, a professional employer organization, and both are owned by the same private equity firm, Aquiline Capital. As of this research, PrimePay’s own pricing page redirects to CoAdvantage’s site, which raises a real question about whether PrimePay continues as a standalone platform. Netchex has been independently run for 20 years with no comparable ownership changes.

What is PrimePay best known for?

COBRA administration is a longtime, documented PrimePay strength. Netchex also handles benefits administration, including COBRA, through an in-house, licensed benefits team, but doesn’t market COBRA as its own signature capability the way PrimePay does.

What do PrimePay reviewers complain about?

Reviewer feedback found in this research includes reports that platform reports were hard to find and customize, that support slowed down noticeably after implementation, and at least one account of a payroll accuracy error that triggered a tax notice.

How does Netchex support compare to PrimePay?

By the numbers, Netchex: 90% of calls answered in under a minute with first-call resolution, 98% customer satisfaction (97% on the most recent reading), an 8.9/10 G2 support score, and a dedicated Account Manager for every client. PrimePay’s own support and satisfaction scores aren’t documented in this research, though reviewers report support slowing down after implementation.

Does Netchex include Time & Attendance and Benefits Administration?

Yes. Time & Attendance is a native Netchex module, and Benefits Administration runs through an in-house, licensed benefits team. PrimePay includes both as well, with COBRA administration cited as a particular strength.

Which company is the better fit for a lean HR team at a multi-location or hourly business?

Netchex is built for lean HR teams at hourly, multi-location, and service-based businesses in the 50-5,000 employee range. PrimePay’s best-fit profile isn’t documented in this research, and its 2025 merger with the PEO CoAdvantage suggests its near-term focus may be shifting toward co-employment arrangements rather than standalone HCM software.

Compare More Providers