5 Best TMA Payroll Alternatives for Indianapolis Small Businesses in 2026

A three-chair barbershop in Broad Ripple just hired its first W-2 employee. A professional services firm downtown is tired of chasing down overtime hours by hand. Both are the kind of small Indianapolis business that ends up on TMA Payroll’s client list, and both are also exactly the businesses that eventually start comparing TMA Payroll alternatives. This guide covers five worth a look, and what each one does well.

TMA Payroll is the payroll division of TMA Small Business Accounting, a CPA firm founded in 2000 that’s been serving small businesses, restaurants and professional services firms around Indianapolis for 25 years. Payroll rides on isolved, folded into TMA’s flat monthly fee alongside bookkeeping and tax prep. Owners usually start looking elsewhere once payroll and hourly scheduling become the harder problem, once headcount grows past a very small team, or once they’d rather have a dedicated HR and payroll platform than an accounting-first bundle.

How We Evaluated These TMA Payroll Alternatives

We looked at who builds the payroll software, how support actually works, fit for hourly and growing teams, and what switching looks like. TMA’s own details come from its website, its BBB and Clutch profiles, and public business listings. Details on the other providers come from their own sites and independent review platforms, as of September 2026.

Give credit where it’s due. TMA genuinely bundles accounting and payroll under one flat fee, and none of the five options below will also do your bookkeeping or file your business taxes. If that combination matters most to you, weigh it before you move.

#1 Netchex – Best Overall TMA Payroll Alternative

Netchex was founded in Louisiana more than 20 years ago for the businesses that keep America running: restaurants, hotels, dealerships and clinics. It builds its own payroll, time, HR and benefits platform instead of reselling one, so the team that answers the phone is the team that owns the product.

For a growing small business, that means time and attendance, Scheduler and payroll all share one system, so nobody’s re-keying hours between a separate timekeeping app and a payroll portal. OneScreen Payroll gets most teams through a run in under 15 minutes. A US-based, FPC-certified support team answers 90% of calls in under a minute, every customer gets a dedicated Account Manager, and Netchex works directly with the CPA and benefits broker you already use, so switching doesn’t mean giving up your accountant.

The entire staff, from sales to implementation to service, has been stellar in their delivery. The culture of Netchex is one of a company that demonstrates the importance of relationships with clients.

– David Faunce, Partner, KM Consulting

#2 isolved (Direct) – The Same Engine, Without the Accounting Firm

TMA’s payroll runs on isolved, so some businesses skip the accounting-firm layer and buy isolved directly. isolved’s People Cloud is a broad platform covering payroll, HR records, time, benefits and recruiting through an ApplicantPro integration, and its own FAQ says direct customers get a dedicated support team and account manager.

Going direct changes who picks up the phone, but the software’s own usability complaints come along for the ride, and its published review scores sit below Netchex’s across the board. You’d also lose TMA’s bookkeeping and tax work, since isolved doesn’t do that.

The workflows are click-heavy and not always intuitive. / Support response times have been inconsistent depending on who we’re routed to.

– G2 / Capterra reviewers, 2025

More detail: Netchex vs. isolved comparison.

#3 Paychex Flex – National Reach, Rep-Dependent Service

Paychex has local reps in most US markets, including Indianapolis, plus retirement services and a PEO option. For a business that’s outgrown a small local bureau, the brand alone can feel like a safe next step up.

The recurring complaint is consistency. Service tends to depend on which rep a client gets, and some reviewers describe cycling through several on a single issue before it’s resolved.

I went through 6 reps… and signed 5 power of attorneys and it still isn’t corrected.

– Verified Reviewer, G2

More detail: Netchex vs. Paychex.

#4 Paylocity – Big Integration Library, Steeper Learning Curve

Paylocity offers 350+ native integrations, a compliance dashboard multi-state employers like, and employee engagement tools such as social feeds and peer recognition. For a professional services firm adding staff across state lines, that compliance layer is a real draw.

For a business used to a small accounting firm’s hands-on service, the jump can feel bigger. One analyst site estimates 8 to 12 weeks to implement core modules, and “Poor Customer Support” is the most common complaint tag on its G2 profile.

Our transition to Paylocity was nothing short of atrocious. Our internal team had to self-teach the software due to a convoluted implementation process.

– Reddit user

More detail: Netchex vs. Paylocity.

#5 Gusto – Easy Start, Limited Room to Grow

Gusto is known for a clean interface, unlimited payroll runs on every plan, and month-to-month contracts. A five-person shop leaving a spreadsheet behind could be running payroll the same week it signs up.

It’s built for small, simple setups. Reviewers say it struggles once a business adds multiple states or more complex hourly pay rules, which matters as a TMA-sized client grows past a very small team.

Gusto is not well suited for companies operating in multiple states. It works for simple setups but does not scale well as payroll becomes more complex.

– HR Director, Mid-Market, G2 (2025)

More detail: Netchex vs. Gusto.

How the TMA Payroll Alternatives Compare

Frequently Asked Questions

Related: Netchex vs. TMA Payroll | Netchex vs. isolved comparison | Netchex vs. Paychex

This guide reflects publicly available product information and independent reviewer data (G2, Capterra, Trustpilot, Yelp, Better Business Bureau, Reddit, Software Advice, GetApp) as of 2026. Feature availability may vary by plan. Contact each provider for current details.

Disclaimer: Any product roadmap or future plans provided herein are for informational purposes only. They do not represent a commitment to deliver any material, code, feature, or functionality. Plans may change without notification. The development, release and timing of any features or functionality described remain at the sole discretion of Netchex, its affiliates, and partners. Netchex does not give legal, tax, or accounting advice. You are responsible for ensuring your use of Netchex product meets your individual business and compliance requirements.

Print this page