Retail Turnover After the Holidays: Why It Spikes and What Comes Next

A store manager clocks back in on January 2 and stares at a schedule with more holes than names. Half the seasonal crew is already gone. Some quit before the new year started. Others just stopped showing up once the return line slowed down. Retail turnover after the holidays isn’t a mystery, and it isn’t bad luck. It’s a well-documented, repeatable pattern that costs retailers real money and real disruption at exactly the moment they’re trying to catch their breath. Understanding why it happens, and which HR practices actually blunt it, matters more than most retail leaders realize until they’re short-staffed in February.

Last updated: August 2026

Why Retail Turnover Spikes Every January

The pattern shows up in the government’s own numbers year after year. Retail employment rose by 494,000 workers between October and December 2023 as stores staffed up for the holidays, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Then, in January and February 2024, retail employment fell by 464,000. The seasonal workforce disappeared almost as fast as it showed up.

That’s not a one-year fluke. Look back to 2018 and 2019, before the pandemic scrambled hiring patterns: retailers added 560,000 seasonal workers, then cut 693,000 positions in the layoff that followed, a bigger drop than the buildup itself. The gap has narrowed since 2022. The shape of the curve hasn’t.

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Retail trade holiday employment buildup and layoff, 2017-2024.”

Quits pile on top of the layoffs. BLS JOLTS data put the retail trade quits rate at 2.7% in January 2026, still well above the 2.0% rate for the economy as a whole. Retail workers leave on their own more often than employees in almost any other sector, holidays or not.

Add a weaker seasonal hiring season on top of that and the picture gets worse before it gets better. Retailers planned to hire only 265,000 to 365,000 seasonal workers for the 2025 holiday season, down from 442,000 in 2024 and the lowest total in 15 years, according to NRF data reported by CBS News. Fewer seasonal hires means less of a cushion when permanent staff burn out from the crunch and leave in January instead.

What the Post-Holiday Drop Actually Costs Retailers

Losing that many people isn’t just a scheduling headache. It’s a bill.

Retail job cuts were up nearly 140% year over year heading into the 2025 season, according to outplacement firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas, cited by Marketplace. Some of that reflects deliberate downsizing. A lot of it is stores backfilling roles they never planned to lose.

Turnover research puts a number on what that backfilling costs. A widely cited analysis from the Center for American Progress, pooling more than a dozen academic studies, found that replacing an employee earning under $30,000 a year typically costs about 16% of that worker’s annual salary. For employees earning $30,000 to $50,000, the figure climbs closer to 20%. Multiply that across a multi-location retail chain and the number stops being an abstraction fast.

Hourly turnover in retail runs high even in a calm year. A Korn Ferry survey of more than 100 major U.S. retailers found hourly in-store turnover at 75.8%, up from 68% the prior year, with part-time turnover closer to 85%, per Korn Ferry. That survey is from 2022, but it lines up with what most retail operators already know: the front line churns constantly, and the holidays just compress a year’s worth of churn into eight weeks.

Why So Many Seasonal Hires Don’t Stick Around

Most seasonal hires never intended to stay past January. That’s fine. Some of them were always going to be gone. The real problem shows up in the ones who might have stayed if the job had looked a little different once the rush ended.

Unpredictable scheduling is a big part of it. A June 2025 Gallup study found that 27% of U.S. employees don’t know their schedule at least two weeks out, and 41% say they have little real input into when they work. Workers with low-quality schedules reported far more work-life conflict (57%) than those with predictable ones (39%), and their job satisfaction scored a full point lower on a 10-point scale. When the holiday rush ends and hours get cut without warning, that’s exactly the kind of instability that pushes people out the door.

It doesn’t have to go that way. Macy’s converted 15% of its seasonal hires into permanent roles last year, and a third of its recent hires were returning employees who’d worked there before, according to the National Retail Federation. That’s not an accident. It’s what happens when a retailer treats seasonal staff as a pipeline instead of a disposable stopgap.

Scheduling Practices That Keep People Past January

Here’s where the fix usually starts: the schedule itself. Posting schedules further in advance gives hourly workers a chance to plan child care, a second job, or school around their shifts, instead of scrambling every Sunday night. Cutting hours gradually after the holiday peak, rather than all at once, also softens the blow for staff who counted on that income through January.

Cross-training helps too. A cashier who can also work the stockroom or handle basic customer service issues is easier to schedule around gaps left by departures, and it gives that employee a reason to stay: more hours, more skills, more value to the store. Time and attendance software that gives managers real visibility into hours, overtime, and coverage gaps makes these calls easier to get right in the moment, instead of after the schedule has already fallen apart.

Retailers that treat scheduling as a retention lever, not just a logistics task, tend to hold onto more of their post-holiday staff. It’s a smaller lift than most HR teams expect. It pays off fast.

Retention Tactics That Work Better Than a Bonus

A one-time bonus doesn’t fix a bad schedule. It doesn’t fix a manager who never checks in, either. Retention research keeps landing on a simpler idea: ask people what would make them stay, before they leave.

SHRM has documented a practice called the stay interview, a short, structured conversation where a manager asks an employee directly what keeps them there and what might push them out. Unlike an exit interview, it happens while there’s still time to do something about the answer. For retail, where turnover is constant and managers rarely have time for formal reviews, a five-minute version of this conversation during a slow shift can surface problems long before someone quits.

Fast, clear onboarding matters just as much. A new hire who spends their first week confused about how to clock in, request time off, or check their pay is already halfway to checking out. Onboarding software that gets new hires set up on day one, paperwork done, system access ready, expectations clear, removes one of the most common early friction points. Pair that with an HR platform that gives managers visibility into attendance patterns across locations, and flight risks stop being a surprise.

Turning Seasonal Workers Into Year-Round Staff

The cheapest retail hire is the one you already trained. That’s the logic behind converting strong seasonal workers into permanent staff instead of starting over every fall.

Retailers that plan for conversion early, flagging top performers by early December instead of scrambling in January, tend to keep more of their best seasonal talent. That means giving managers a simple way to note standout hires during the season itself, not after the crowds thin out and the decision feels rushed. Hiring software that keeps seasonal applicants and past employees in one searchable pool makes it faster to bring back the people who worked out, instead of starting the search from zero every peak season.

Timing benefits eligibility and explaining it clearly also matters more than most retailers assume. A seasonal worker who understands exactly when they’d qualify for benefits as a permanent employee has a concrete reason to ask about staying on. For an industry built on hourly, frontline work, retail-specific HR and payroll support that fits how stores actually operate, rather than a generic system built for office staff, makes that whole process easier for everyone involved.

Frequently Asked Questions