Netchex vs. PaySmart Payroll (PA): Which HR and Payroll Platform Is Right for Your Business in 2026?

A nonprofit in Harrisburg is trying to close out payroll before a grant deadline. Twenty miles away, a construction crew foreman is texting in overtime hours from a job site in Cumberland County, and someone in the office still has to key them in by hand. Both could end up calling PaySmart Payroll Services, a small bureau in Mechanicsburg that’s built its business on exactly this kind of client. If you’re comparing Netchex vs. PaySmart Payroll, here’s what actually sits underneath each option.

One quick note before anything else. There are two unrelated companies that use the name PaySmart Payroll Services. This guide is about the one headquartered in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania. There’s a separate, unaffiliated Paysmart Payroll Services, LLC based in Greenville, South Carolina, and the two don’t share ownership, staff or software. Make sure you’re reading about the right one before you make a call.

The core difference is structural. PaySmart runs its payroll on Execupay’s PlatinumPay Xpress, a product Execupay builds and licenses to bureaus like PaySmart. Netchex writes its own payroll, time, HR and benefits software and staffs its own support desk. That single fact shapes almost everything else below.

Last updated: September 2026. PaySmart Payroll information comes from the company’s own website and public business listings. Netchex figures come from G2 and Netchex’s own customer data.

The Short Version

PaySmart Payroll Services has served small and midsize employers from Mechanicsburg since 2002, according to its own site, with clients mostly across Central Pennsylvania and additional payroll processed in other states. It names construction, healthcare, retail, restaurants and hospitality, municipalities, and nonprofits and religious organizations among the industries it serves. Clients are assigned a New Client Concierge during onboarding and a Current Client Concierge afterward, the team includes Certified Payroll Professionals, and the company commits to responding to inquiries within 24 hours. That’s a genuinely client-focused setup for a small bureau.

Netchex was founded in Louisiana more than 20 years ago for the businesses that keep America running: restaurants, hotels, dealerships, clinics. It’s one company from the code to the phone line. The US-based, FPC-certified support team answers 90% of calls in under a minute, customers rate that service 4.8 out of 5, and Netchex holds an 8.9/10 Quality of Support score on G2.

Company Overview

Netchex vs. PaySmart Payroll on Payroll and Time

Here’s the thing about a job-costed payroll. A construction crew that moves between three sites in a week needs hours tagged correctly the first time, not fixed after the fact. PaySmart lists standard payroll, online payroll entry and employee self-service among its services, all delivered through PlatinumPay Xpress, the platform Execupay builds. PaySmart configures and supports it locally, but the underlying product, its release schedule and its feature set come from Execupay, not from PaySmart itself.

Netchex owns both halves of that equation. Time and attendance and Scheduler live in the same system as payroll, so crew hours and overtime rules flow straight through without crossing from one company’s product into another’s. OneScreen Payroll pulls onboarding, overtime, benefits and taxes into a single readiness view before a run goes out, and most teams finish in under 15 minutes.

HR, Benefits and Compliance

PaySmart’s site lists HR Services alongside its payroll offering, plus a structured process for new hires, employee changes and separations, each with its own guided paperwork. For a small nonprofit or a retail shop without a dedicated HR person, having someone walk through that paperwork is genuinely useful.

Netchex takes a different approach: everything lives on one employee record. With its in-house benefits solution, enrollment, ACA tracking, onboarding and hiring through Netchex Recruit all pull from the same data, so a new hire’s information doesn’t get typed in three separate times. ACA Central tracks hours and coverage offers across full-time, part-time and seasonal staff, and Netchex files Forms 1094-C and 1095-C. (The IRS reporting rules for applicable large employers spell out what’s required as headcount grows.) Netchex also works directly with a client’s existing CPA and benefits broker, so switching payroll doesn’t mean switching those relationships too.

Service and Support

PaySmart clients say the team picks up the phone and stays pleasant about it. One writes: “PaySmart has been doing our payroll for 20 years and we love them.” Another says, “whenever I call, I get a live person who addresses my needs quickly.” A third puts it simply: “They are always quick to respond to my questions, charge reasonable rates with no hidden fees.” For a small local bureau, that kind of loyalty doesn’t happen by accident.

Still, worth understanding how the pieces fit together. Because PlatinumPay Xpress is licensed software, a problem that lives inside the platform itself typically has to move from PaySmart’s team up to Execupay before it gets resolved. Day-to-day questions stay local. A software-level bug doesn’t.

Netchex removes that extra hop. The company that writes the code also answers the phone, 90% of calls get picked up in under a minute with first-call resolution, and every customer has a dedicated Account Manager.

Netchex has the best support of any service provider I’ve ever worked with. There aren’t any hoops to jump through with Netchex support.

– Mary Lang, Accounting and Financial Control Director, Atlanta Air Charter

Implementation and Switching

PaySmart doesn’t publish an implementation timeline or its pricing on its website. If you’re comparing quotes, ask for both in writing, and ask specifically which parts of setup PaySmart handles versus what runs through Execupay’s own systems.

Netchex implementation is free and project-managed, usually wrapping up in about six weeks, with free data imports and a 96% implementation satisfaction score. One team owns it from the first data pull to the first live payroll.

Who Each Is Built For

PaySmart Payroll (PA) may fit if: you’re a small or midsize employer in Central Pennsylvania, you want a named concierge and a 24-hour response commitment from a local team, and you’re comfortable with Execupay as the software underneath.

Netchex may fit if: you run hourly or multi-location teams, you want one company accountable for both the platform and the support, and you’d rather not wonder whose desk a software problem lands on. For more on how Netchex stacks up elsewhere, see our Netchex vs. ADP.

Frequently Asked Questions

Related: 5 Best PaySmart Payroll Alternatives | Netchex vs. ADP | Netchex vs. Paylocity

This guide reflects publicly available product information and independent reviewer data (G2, Capterra, Trustpilot, Yelp, Better Business Bureau, Reddit, Software Advice, GetApp) as of 2026. Feature availability may vary by plan. Contact each provider for current details.

Disclaimer: Any product roadmap or future plans provided herein are for informational purposes only. They do not represent a commitment to deliver any material, code, feature, or functionality. Plans may change without notification. The development, release and timing of any features or functionality described remain at the sole discretion of Netchex, its affiliates, and partners. Netchex does not give legal, tax, or accounting advice. You are responsible for ensuring your use of Netchex product meets your individual business and compliance requirements.

Print this page